Let’s reason step-by-step. **1. Company context** ENI S.p.A. is a large Italian energy company. From the data, we can see: - It has significant property, plant, and equipment (€56.3bn in 2022, €56.3bn in 2021), typical of a capital-intensive industry. - Revenue is very large and volatile due to commodity prices (€132.5bn in 2022 vs €76.6bn in 2021 and €44.0bn in 2020). - Profitability swings widely: from -€8.6bn in 2020 to €13.9bn in 2022. - Financial leverage is significant: total liabilities €96.9bn, equity €55.2bn, a Debt/Equity of about 1.75x. - Operating cash flows are strong but variable. **2. Hybrid bonds characteristics** Hybrid bonds have equity-like features (subordination, coupon deferral) and are treated partly as equity by rating agencies. They are most suitable for: - Investment-grade companies - Capital-intensive industries with stable or predictable cash flows - Firms wanting to protect their credit rating while raising capital **3. ENI’s situation** - Its earnings are highly cyclical (oil & gas price exposure). - Heavy reliance on hybrid bonds could increase financial risk if commodity prices fall sharply (2020 loss was massive). - Hybrids usually carry higher coupons than senior debt, so if cash flows are volatile, fixed obligations can become burdensome. - A moderate use (e.g., up to ~25% of total capital structure) could be justified to optimize the cost of capital without endangering rating thresholds or liquidity. **4. Conclusions** Given ENI’s credit profile, volatility, and existing debt levels, a limited reliance on hybrids seems prudent. Moving to 50% or above would be too risky for such a cyclical business. Pure equity or pure debt extremes are unsuitable. 25%